Month: March 2025

AI’s Real Revolution Is Just Beginning

Thank you to The Globe for publishing my op-ed about AI last week. In it, I draw parallels between the dot-com crash and the current AI boom—keeping in mind the old saying, “History doesn’t repeat itself, but it often rhymes.” The piece also explores how the atomic unit of this transformation is the ever-declining “cost of intelligence.” AI is the first technology in human history capable of learning, reasoning, creativity, cross-domain thinking, and decision-making. This fundamental shift will impact every sector, without exception, spurring the rise of new tech giants and inevitable casualties in the process. The key is knowing which land to grab!

The piece is now available below.

In the past month, everyone I spoke to has been talking about DeepSeek and Nvidia. Is Nvidia facing extinction? Have certain tech giants overspent on AI? Are we seeing a bubble about to burst, or just another public market overreaction? And what about traditional sectors, like industrials, that haven’t yet felt AI’s impact?

Let’s step back. We’ll revisit companies that soared or collapsed during the dot-com crash – and the lessons we can learn. As Mark Twain reputedly said, “History doesn’t repeat itself, but it often rhymes.”

The answer is that the reports of Nvidia’s demise are greatly exaggerated, though other companies face greater danger. At the same time, new opportunities are vast because this AI-driven shift could dwarf past tech disruptions.

Before 2000, the dot-com mania hit full speed. High-flying infrastructure players such as Global Crossing – once worth US$47-billion – provided backbone networks. Cisco delivered networking equipment, and Sun Microsystems built servers. However, amid the crash, Global Crossing went bankrupt in January, 2002. Cisco plummeted from more than US$500-billion in market cap to about $100-billion. Sun Microsystems sank from a US$200-billion market cap to under US$10-billion.

They failed or shrank for different reasons. Global Crossing needed huge investments before real revenue arrived. Cisco had decent unit economics but lost pricing power when open networking standards commoditized its gear. Sun Microsystems suffered when cheaper hardware and free, open-source software (such as Linux and Apache) undercut it, and commodity hardware plus cloud computing made its servers irrelevant.

However, these companies did not decline because they were infrastructure providers. They declined because they failed to identify the right business model before their capital ran out or were disrupted by alternatives, including open or free systems, despite having the first-mover advantage.

Meanwhile, other infrastructure players thrived. Amazon, seen mostly as an e-commerce site, earned 70 per cent of its operating profit from Amazon Web Services – hosting startups and big players such as Netflix. AWS eliminated the need to buy hardware and continually cut prices, especially in its earlier years, catalyzing a new wave of businesses and ultimately driving demand while increasing AWS’s revenue.

In hindsight, the dot-com boom was real – it simply took time for usage to catch up to the hype. By the late 2000s, mobile, social and cloud surged. Internet-native giants (Netflix, Google, etc.) grew quickly with products that truly fit the medium. Early front-runners such as Yahoo! and eBay faded. Keep in mind that Facebook was founded in 2004, well after the crash, and Apple shifted from iPods to the revolutionary iPhone in 2007, which further catalyzed the internet explosion. A first-mover advantage might not always pay off.

The first lesson we learned is that open systems disrupt and commoditize infrastructure. At that time, and we are seeing it again, an army of contributors drove open systems for free, allowing them to out-innovate proprietary solutions.

Companies that compete directly against open systems – note that Nvidia does not – are particularly vulnerable at the infrastructure layer when many open and free alternatives (such as those solely building LLMs without any applications) exist. DeepSeek, for example, was inevitable – this is how technology evolves.

Open standards, open source and other open systems dramatically lower costs, reduce barriers to AI adoption and undermine incumbents’ pricing power by offering free, high-quality alternatives. This “creative destruction” drives technological progress.

In other words, OpenAI is in a vulnerable position, as it resembles the software side of Sun Microsystems – competing with free alternatives such as Linux. It also requires significant capital to build out, yet its infrastructure is rapidly becoming commoditized, much like Global Crossing’s situation. On the other hand, Nvidia has a strong portfolio of proprietary technologies with few commoditized alternatives, making its position relatively secure. Nvidia is not the new Sun Microsystems or Cisco.

Most importantly, the disruption and commoditization of infrastructure also democratize AI innovation. Until recently, starting an AI company often required raising millions – if not tens of millions – just to get off the ground. That is already changing, as numerous fast-growing companies have started and scaled with minimal initial capital. This is leading to an explosion of innovative startups and further accelerating the flywheel.

The next lesson we learned is that the internet was the first technology in human history that was borderless, connected, ubiquitous, real-time, and free. Its atomic unit is connectivity. During its rise, “the cost of connectivity” steadily declined, while productivity gains from increased connectivity continued to expand demand. The flywheel turned faster and faster, forming a virtuous cycle.

Similarly, AI is the first technology in human history capable of learning, reasoning, creativity, cross-domain functions and decision-making. Crucially, AI’s influence is no longer confined to preprogrammed software running on computing devices; it now extends into all types of machines. Hardware and software, combined with collective learning, enable autonomous cars and other systems like robots to adapt intelligently in real time with little or no predefined instructions.

These breakthroughs are reaching sectors scarcely touched by the internet revolution, including manufacturing and energy. This goes beyond simple digitization; we are entering an era of autonomous operations and, ultimately, autonomous businesses, allowing humans to focus on higher-value tasks.

As with connectivity costs in the internet era, in this AI era, “the cost of intelligence” has been steadily declining. Meanwhile, the value derived from increased intelligence continues to grow, driving further demand – this mirrors how the internet played out and is already happening again for AI. The parallels between these two platform shifts suggest that massive economic value will be created or shifted from incumbents, opening substantial investment opportunities across early-stage ventures, growth-stage private markets and public investments.

Just as the early internet boom heavily focused on infrastructure, a significant amount of capital has been invested in enabling AI technologies. However, over time, economic value shifts from infrastructure to applications – just as it did with the internet.

This doesn’t mean there are no opportunities in AI infrastructure – far from it. Remember, more than half of Amazon’s profits come from AWS. Services, such as AWS, that provide access to AI, will continue to benefit as demand soars. Similarly, Nvidia will continue to benefit from the rising demand. However, many of today’s most-valuable companies – both public and private – are in the application layer or operate full-stack models.

Despite these advancements, this transformation won’t happen overnight, but it will likely unfold more quickly than the internet disruption – which took more than a decade – because many core technologies for rapid innovation are already in place.

AI revenues might appear modest today and don’t yet show up in the public markets. However, if we look closer, some AI-native startups are already growing at an unprecedented pace. The disruption isn’t a prediction; it’s already happening.

As Bill Gates once said, “Most people overestimate what they can achieve in one year and underestimate what they can achieve in ten years.”

The AI revolution is just beginning. The next decade will bring enormous opportunities – and a new wave of tech giants, alongside inevitable casualties.

It’s a land grab – you just need to know which land to seize!

P.S. If you enjoyed this blog post, please take a minute to like, comment, subscribe and share. Thank you for reading!

This blog is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. You are free to copy, redistribute, remix, transform, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given.

Network Effect is Dead. Long Live Network Effect.

When Two Small Fish first started in 2015, we formulated our “Thesis 1.0” to focus on network effects exclusively. We leveraged our hands-on product experience in scaling Wattpad from 0 to 100 million users—essentially a marketplace for readers and writers—and applied a similar lens to other verticals, both in B2C and B2B.

It worked incredibly well for TSF because, at the time, network effects were the holy grail for defensibility, yet they were often misunderstood (for example, going viral is not the same as having network effects, and simply operating a marketplace does not guarantee strong network effects!). Our skill is more transferable than you might think!

So, Eva created the ASSET framework, which helped us identify the best network-effect investment opportunities and, more importantly, helped entrepreneurs understand and increase their network effect coefficient—the measure of true network effects—and ultimately embed strong network effects into their products. In short:

• A stands for “atomic unit”

• S stands for “seed the supply side”

• The other S stands for “scale the demand side”

• E stands for “enlarge the network effect” or “enhance the network coefficient”

• T stands for “track proprietary insights”

This framework provided a simple yet systematic way to judge whether a company truly had network effects or merely the illusion of them.

However, toward the end of the last decade, it became increasingly difficult to find investable network-effect opportunities. Well-established incumbents already had very strong network effects in place, effectively setting the world order. It became exceedingly difficult for emerging disruptors—both in consumer and enterprise spaces—to find a gap to break through.

We began looking for other forms of technology defensibility (for example, semiconductors) and gradually moved away from “shallow tech” network-effect investments, as we found very few investable opportunities. In fact, our last shallow tech investment was made about three years ago.

Then, in late 2022, ChatGPT arrived.

As the world now understands, generative AI is the first technology in human history capable of learning, reasoning, creativity, cross-domain functionality, and decision-making. It’s the most significant platform shift since mobile, social, and cloud computing in the late 2010s—and arguably the biggest one in human history. It also means the playing field has been leveled. Today, there are numerous ways to create new products with powerful network effects that can render incumbents’ offerings obsolete (for example, I haven’t used Google Search regularly for a long time) because newcomers can disrupt incumbents from all three angles: technology, product, and commercialization (e.g., business models). Incumbents are vulnerable!

On the other hand, the ASSET framework also needed a refresh, as we’re no longer dealing with simple, well-understood marketplaces. What if one side of the marketplace is now AI? Even though our original framework was designed to handle data-driven network effects, the speed and scale of data generation have multiplied by orders of magnitude. How does this affect enlarging the network effects and increasing the coefficient?

The good news is that there are now ways to massively increase the network effect coefficient in a remarkably short time. The bad news is that all your competitors—large or small—can do the same. Competition has never been fiercer.

After ChatGPT was released, we quickly revised our ASSET framework to version 2.0. Since then, we’ve been guest-lecturing this masterclass worldwide for well over a year. By fully leveraging AI’s creativity and reasoning capabilities, entrepreneurs can now harness human-machine collaboration to supercharge both the demand and supply sides, blitz-scale, and create new atomic units. Here’s the gist of 2.0:

• A – Atomic Unit of Product

• S – Super Seed the Supply Side (now amplified by Gen AI)

• S – Supercharge the Demand Side (now leveraging Gen AI)

• E – Exponential Engagement (using the human + AI combo)

• T – Transform Business with New AI-powered Atomic Units

Like 1.0, this new framework is easy to understand but difficult to master—and it’s even more complex now because, with Gen AI, it’s non-linear. Our masterclass covers the lecture material, but the real work happens in our private tutoring, where execution matters—and this is how we help our portfolio companies win.

The old network effect is dead. Thanks to the AI platform shift, network effects are roaring back in a different and far more potent way in the new world order. The combination of deep tech defensibility plus network effect defensibility is the new holy grail—and we are specialized in both.

With the AI platform shift, all of a sudden, there are many new investable opportunities that didn’t exist before. At the same time, the ground has shifted: the old playbook is out, and the new playbook is in. It’s exciting; we love the challenge, and we wouldn’t have it any other way.

P.S. If you enjoyed this blog post, please take a minute to like, comment, subscribe and share. Thank you for reading!

This blog is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. You are free to copy, redistribute, remix, transform, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given.

Investing in Fibra: Revolutionizing Women’s Health with Smart Underwear

At Two Small Fish Ventures, we love backing founders who are not only transforming user behaviour but also unlocking new and impactful value. That’s why we’re excited to announce our investment in Fibra, a pioneering company redefining wearable technology to improve women’s health. We are proud to be the lead investor in this round, and I will be joining as a board observer. 

The Vision Behind Fibra

Fibra is developing smart underwear embedded with proprietory textile-based sensors for seamless, non-invasive monitoring of previously untapped vital biomarkers. Their innovative technology provides continuous, accurate health insights—all within the comfort of everyday clothing. Learning from user data, it then provides personalized insights, helping women track, plan, and optimize their reproductive health with ease. This AI-driven approach enhances the precision and effectiveness of health monitoring, empowering users with actionable information tailored to their unique needs. 

Fibra has already collected millions of data points with its product, further strengthening its AI capabilities and improving the accuracy of its health insights. While Fibra’s initial focus is female fertility tracking, its platform has the potential to expand into broader areas of women’s health, including pregnancy detection/monitoring, menopause, detection of STDs and cervical cancer and many more, fundamentally transforming how we monitor and understand our bodies.

Perfect Founder-Market Fit

Fibra was founded by Parnian Majd, an exceptional leader in biomedical innovation. She holds a Master of Engineering in Biomedical Engineering from the University of Toronto and a Bachelor’s degree in Biomedical Engineering from TMU. Her achievements have been widely recognized, including being an EY Women in Tech Award recipient, a Rogers Women Empowerment Award finalist for Innovation, and more.

We are thrilled to support Parnian and the Fibra team as they push the boundaries of AI-driven smart textiles and health monitoring. We are entering a golden age of deep-tech innovation and software-hardware convergence—a space we are excited to champion at Two Small Fish Ventures.

Stay tuned as Fibra advances its mission to empower women through cutting-edge health technology.

This blog is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. You are free to copy, redistribute, remix, transform, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given.

Announcing Our Investment in Hepzibah AI

The Two Small Fish team is thrilled to announce our investment in Hepzibah AI, a new venture founded by Untether AI’s co-founders, serial entrepreneurs Martin Snelgrove and Raymond Chik, along with David Lynch and Taneem Ahmed. Their mission is to bring next-generation, energy-efficient AI inference technologies to market, transforming how AI compute is integrated into everything from consumer electronics to industrial systems. We are proud to be the lead investor in this round, and I will be joining as a board observer to support Hepzibah AI as they build the future of AI inference.

The Vision Behind Hepzibah AI

Hepzibah AI is built on the breakthrough energy-efficient AI inference compute architecture pioneered at Untether AI—but takes it even further. In addition to pushing performance/power harder, it can handle training loads like distillation, and it provides supercomputer-style networking on-chip. Their business model focuses on providing IP and core designs that chipmakers can incorporate into their system-on-chip designs. Rather than manufacturing AI chips themselves, Hepzibah AI will license its advanced AI inference IP for integration into a wide variety of devices and products.

Hepzibah AI’s tagline, “Extreme Full-stack AI: from models to metals,” perfectly encapsulates their vision. They are tackling AI from the highest levels of software optimization down to the most fundamental aspects of hardware architecture, ensuring that AI inference is not only more powerful but also dramatically more efficient.

Why does this matter? AI is rapidly becoming as indispensable as the CPU has been for the past few decades. Today, many modern chips, especially system-on-chip (SoC) devices, include a CPU or MCU core, and increasingly, those same chips will require AI capabilities to keep up with the growing demand for smarter, more efficient processing.

This approach allows Hepzibah AI to focus on programmability and adaptable hardware configurations, ensuring they stay ahead of the rapidly evolving AI landscape. By providing best-in-class AI inference IP, Hepzibah AI is in a prime position to capture this massive opportunity.

An Exceptional Founding Team

Martin Snelgrove and Raymond Chik are luminaries in this space—I’ve known them for decades. David Lynch and Taneem Ahmed also bring deep industry expertise, having spent years building and commercializing cutting-edge silicon and software products.

Their collective experience in this rapidly expanding, soon-to-be ubiquitous industry makes investing in Hepzibah AI a clear choice. We can’t wait to see what they accomplish next.

P.S. You may notice that the logo is a curled skunk. I’d like to highlight that the skunk’s eyes are zeros from the MNIST dataset. 🙂 

This blog is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. You are free to copy, redistribute, remix, transform, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given.

Contrarian Series: Your TAM is Zero? We love it!

Note: One of the most common pieces of feedback we receive from entrepreneurs is that TSF partners don’t think, act, or speak like typical VCs. The Contrarian Series is meant to demystify this, so founders know more about us before pitching.

Just before New Year, I was speaking at the TBDC Venture Day Conference together with BetaKit CEO Siri Agrell and Serial Entrepreneur and former MP Frank Baylis.

When I said “Two Small Fish love Zero TAM businesses,” I said it so matter-of-factly that the crowd was taken aback. I even saw quite a few posts on social media that said, “I can’t believe Allen Lau said it!”

Of course, any business will need to go after a non-zero TAM eventually. But hear me out.

Here’s what I did at Wattpad: I never had a “total addressable market” slide in the early days. I just said, “There are five billion people who can read and write, and I want to capture them all!”

Even when we became a scaleup, I kept the same line. I just said, “There are billions of people who can read, write, or watch our movies, and I want to capture them all!”

Naturally, some VCs tried to box me into the “publishing tool” category or other buckets they deemed appropriate. But Wattpad didn’t really fit into anything that existed at the time. Trust me, I tried to find a box I would fit in too, but none felt natural.

Why? That’s because Wattpad was a category creator. And, of course, that meant our TAM was effectively zero.

In other words, we made our own TAM.

Many of our portfolio companies are also category creators, so their decks often don’t have a TAM slide either.

Yes, any venture-backed company eventually needs a large TAM. And, of course, I don’t mean to suggest that every startup needs to be a category creator.

That said, we’re perfectly fine—in fact, sometimes we even prefer—seeing a pitch deck without a TAM slide. By definition, category creators have first-mover advantages. More importantly, category creators in a large, winner-take-all market—especially those with strong moats—tend to be extremely valuable at scale and, hence, highly investable.

So, founders, if your company is poised to create a large category, skip the TAM slide when pitching to Two Small Fish. We love it!

P.S. Don’t forget, if you have an “exit strategy” slide in your pitch deck, please remove it before pitching to us. TYSM!

This blog is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. You are free to copy, redistribute, remix, transform, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given.

Celebrating the Unintended but Obvious Impact of Wattpad on International Women’s Day

It’s been almost three years since I stepped aside from my role as CEO of Wattpad, yet I’m still amazed by the reactions I get when I bump into people who have been part of the Wattpad story. The impact continues to surface in unexpected and inspiring ways frequently.

Wattpad has always been a platform built on storytelling for all ages and genders. That being said, our core demographic—roughly 50% of our users—has been teenage girls. Young women have always played a pivotal role in the Wattpad community.

Next year, Wattpad will turn 20 (!)—a milestone that feels both surreal and deeply rewarding. When we started in 2006, we couldn’t have imagined the journey ahead. But one thing is certain: our early users have grown up, and many of them are now in their 20s and 30s, making their mark on the world in remarkable ways.

A perfect example: at our recent masterclass at the University of Toronto, I ran into Nour. A decade ago, she was pulling all-nighters reading on Wattpad. Today, she’s an Engineering Science student at the University of Toronto, specializing in machine intelligence. Her story is not unique. Over the years, I’ve met countless female Wattpad users who are now scientists, engineers, and entrepreneurs, building startups and pushing boundaries in STEM fields.

This is incredibly fulfilling. Many of them have told me that they looked up to Wattpad and our journey as a source of inspiration. The idea that something we built has played even a small role in shaping their ambitions is humbling.

Now, as an investor at Two Small Fish, I’m excited about the prospect of supporting these entrepreneurs in the next stage of their journey. Some of these Wattpad users will go on to build the next great startups, and it would be incredible to be part of their success, just as they were part of Wattpad’s.

On this International Women’s Day, I want to celebrate this unintended but, in hindsight, obvious outcome: a generation of young women who grew up on Wattpad are now stepping into leadership roles in tech and beyond. They are the next wave of innovators, creators, and entrepreneurs, and I can’t wait to see what they build next.

P.S. This blog is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. You are free to copy, redistribute, remix, transform, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given.

Celebrating Richard Sutton’s Turing Award

I’d like to extend my heartfelt congratulations to Richard Sutton, co-founder of Openmind Research Institute and a pioneer in Reinforcement Learning, for being honoured with the 2024 Turing Award—often described as the “Nobel Prize of Computing.” This accolade reflects his groundbreaking contributions, which have shaped modern AI across a wide spectrum of applications, from LLMs to robotics and everything in between. His influence resonates throughout classrooms, research, and everyday life worldwide.

As a self-professed science nerd, I’ve had the privilege and honour of working with him through the Openmind board. Rich co-founded Openmind alongside Randy Goebel and Joseph Modayil as a non-profit focused on conducting fundamental AI research to better understand minds. We believe that the greatest breakthroughs in AI are still ahead of us, and that basic research lays the groundwork for future commercial and technological innovations.

A core principle of Openmind—and a guiding philosophy of its co-founders—is a commitment to open research: there are no intellectual property restrictions on its work, ensuring everyone can contribute to and build upon this shared body of knowledge. Rich’s vision and dedication continue to inspire researchers and practitioners around the world to push the boundaries of AI and openly share their insights. This Turing Award is a well-deserved recognition of his transformative impact, and I can’t wait to see the breakthroughs that lie ahead as his work continues to redefine our understanding of intelligence.

P.S. This blog is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. You are free to copy, redistribute, remix, transform, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given.